Pedal Kayak vs. Paddle Kayak: Which to Choose

Pedal or paddle? That’s the question many kayakers have when choosing their next kayak—and for new kayakers to consider before they take the plunge. So, when it comes to pedal or paddle kayaks for fishing, which one should you choose?

The reality is that there are pros and cons for both styles, which we’ll be discussing in-depth so that you can make an informed decision based on the type of experience you want.

Benefits of a Pedal Kayak

When people think of a kayak, images of paddles come to mind. However, pedal kayaks are growing in popularity and offer many benefits over a paddle kayak. Pedal kayaks are a great choice for both recreational paddling and fishing.

Hands-Free on the Water

One of the most obvious benefits of a pedal kayak is that it’s hands-free kayaking. You don’t have to tire out your arms paddling on the water and instead use your legs to propel the kayak. Pedals allow you to control your kayak’s position by using your legs and the rudder steering handle.

The Best Option for Fishing

Pedal kayaks are a great option for fishing as they allow you to stay put in one spot while baiting your line. Kayaks with pedals provide an increase in power, let you get to your destination quicker, and provide less of a disturbance to the water and fish below. With a pedal kayak, you can troll while handling a fishing rod. Find a fishing life jacket specifically for anglers to optimize your storage and maneuverability. 

Pedal Kayaks Offer Speed

Pedal kayaks offer a faster way to get around the water. Not only do you get more speed, but pedal kayaks are more efficient at getting you to your fishing spot. You can cover larger bodies of water easier than if you were to use paddles while also maintaining a higher speed.

The Best Pedal Kayak for All Occasions

From our perspective, the Malibu Pedal Kayak is one of the best pedal kayaks on the market. The fun Malibu hull is complemented by thoughtful fishing features that make it an ideal choice for a fishing kayak. A true do-it-all pedal kayak, this easily maneuvered kayak can turn any outing into a memorable adventure. 

A fishing kayak should be both easy to maneuver and transport. The Topwater 106 PDL is a comfortable, hands-free performance fishing kayak with unmatched stability and precision handling in a compact size. Sneak up on fish with the quietest pontoon-style hull on the market. 

Benefits of a Paddle Kayak

Just like pedal kayaks, paddle kayaks offer benefits depending on the experience you’re after. 

All the Legroom

The addition of a pedal drive means that you’re passing up on extra legroom. If you’re uncomfortable with the room you lose with a pedal drive, stick with a paddle-driven kayak. Generally, paddle kayaks also offer a bit more room for gear, allowing you to stash away more fishing equipment, snacks and beverages, and hunting accessories if you’re planning to go on a duck hunt. 

Easier On Your Wallet

Paddle kayaks tend to cost less than their pedal-driven counterparts. The additional tech that comes with pedal kayaks can add additional costs to your purchase. The money that you save with a paddle kayak can be used to purchase accessories like upgraded seating and storage or a kayak cart for easier transportation. 

Paddle Kayaks Weigh Less

Compared to their pedal counterparts, paddle kayaks weigh less, adding to their maneuverability and transportation abilities. When thinking about your own strength, the weight of your kayak will make a difference—often, a paddle kayak is the best option when considering transportation. 

Our Top Paddle Kayak for Fishing

When it comes to fishing, there’s no match for the Malibu Two XL Angler. It can be paddled solo or tandem, which is a great option if your kids want to get involved. There is over 450 lbs of capacity, great stability, and paddle holders located on the bow to effortlessly stash your paddles when you just want to float on the water. 

Where Do You Plan On Kayaking?

A key component to make the decision between pedal vs. paddle is where you plan on kayaking. Pedal kayaks won’t perform as well in shallow water, making paddle the ideal choice because you can easily steer where you are going using the paddle touching the bottom. If you are kayaking on open, windier waters, pedal kayaks are often the safest choice. You’re less likely to get tired, can move quickly over larger bodies of water, and can get to shore if the weather takes a sudden turn for the worst. 

Comparing Cost Between Pedal and Paddle

As we talked about earlier, paddle kayaks can be less expensive than pedal kayaks. This is because of the added technology that goes into the pedal kayaks. For those who are just starting out, paddle may be a better option for the budget conscious or recreational paddler. But, spending additional money on a pedal has its benefits, too. The ease of use, hands-free enjoyment, and speed are major factors for many kayakers.

Pedal vs. Paddle: The Choice Is as Unique as Your Experience

It’s all up to the individual kayaker when it comes down to pedal vs. paddle. Consider costs, where you’re most likely to kayak, and weigh the pros and cons between the two. Whatever you pick ultimately decides on the kind of experience you want on the water. No matter what you decide on, adventure awaits!